1-9 A-D E-G H-M N-P Q-S T-Z

EDTA

EDTA, short for ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid, is a synthetic aminopolycarboxylic acid that grips dissolved metal ions and holds them in solution as stable, water-soluble complexes. Water treatment professionals call this chelation, and they call the product a chelating agent, chelant, sequestrant or complexing agent depending on the trade they came up in. One molecule of EDTA binds one metal ion. Once bound, calcium can no longer deposit as carbonate or sulfate scale, iron can no longer stain or foul, and copper can no longer plate out on steel.

In water treatment, EDTA and its sodium and ammonium salts do four distinct jobs:

1. Preventing scale in steam boilers by keeping residual feedwater hardness soluble (the classic chelant program).
2. Dissolving existing deposits, from calcium sulfate on a reverse osmosis membrane to magnetite inside a utility boiler tube.
3. Controlling trace metals in process water so that bleaching, dyeing, washing and polymerisation steps run consistently.
4. Measuring water hardness, because the standard laboratory hardness test is itself an EDTA titration.

This page is written for the people who specify, formulate and buy the chemical: water treatment service companies, blenders of boiler and cooling water products, membrane plant operators, power station chemists, R&D formulators and purchasing teams. It explains which form of EDTA suits which duty, how much is needed, where EDTA is the wrong choice, and what documentation to ask for when sourcing it.

A note on the numbers used throughout. Dosing factors and dissolving capacities are derived from molecular weights and the fixed 1:1 binding ratio, so they do not go out of date. Operating limits quoted for boilers and membranes reflect long-established industry practice and equipment manufacturers' published guidance; your own equipment manuals and treatment programme always take precedence.


PRODUCT IDENTITY: CAS NUMBER, EC NUMBER, FORMULA AND SYNONYMS

"EDTA" on a purchase order is not specific enough. The acid and its tetrasodium salt differ roughly a thousand-fold in solubility and by more than eight pH units. The identifiers below remove the ambiguity.

EDTA acid (free acid)
Chemical name: Ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid
IUPAC name: 2,2',2'',2'''-(ethane-1,2-diyldinitrilo)tetraacetic acid
CAS No: 60-00-4
EC (EINECS) No: 200-449-4
Molecular formula: C10H16N2O8
Structural formula: (HOOC-CH2)2N-CH2-CH2-N(CH2-COOH)2
Molecular weight: 292.24 g/mol
Shorthand: H4EDTA or H4Y

Tetrasodium EDTA (EDTA 4Na, Na4EDTA) - the main water treatment grade
CAS No: 64-02-8 (anhydrous), 13235-36-4 (tetrahydrate), 10378-23-1 (dihydrate)
EC No: 200-573-9
Molecular formula: C10H12N2Na4O8
Molecular weight: 380.17 g/mol (anhydrous), 452.23 g/mol (tetrahydrate)

Disodium EDTA dihydrate (EDTA 2Na, Na2EDTA)
CAS No: 6381-92-6 (dihydrate), 139-33-3 (anhydrous)
EC No: 205-358-3
Molecular weight: 372.24 g/mol (dihydrate)

Trisodium EDTA
CAS No: 150-38-9
EC No: 205-758-8

Calcium disodium EDTA
CAS No: 62-33-9
EC No: 200-529-9

Ammonium salts used in industrial chemical cleaning (diammonium EDTA and tetraammonium EDTA) are normally supplied as aqueous solutions or prepared on site from EDTA acid and ammonia.

Synonyms and names you will meet in specifications, tenders and search results: edetic acid, edetate, EDTA acid, ethylenedinitrilotetraacetic acid, (ethylenedinitrilo)tetraacetic acid, ethylene diamine tetra acetic acid, tetrasodium edetate, edetate disodium, sodium EDTA, EDTA tetrasodium salt, EDTA disodium salt, EDTA Na4, EDTA Na2. Older literature and legacy specifications also use trade names owned by various manufacturers, such as Versene, Trilon B, Dissolvine, Sequestrene, Komplexon and Titriplex; chemically they refer to EDTA or its salts.


HOW EDTA WORKS: CHELATION EXPLAINED FOR WATER CHEMISTS

Picture the molecule as a two-carbon bridge with a nitrogen atom at each end, and two acetic acid arms hanging from each nitrogen. That gives six electron-donating sites: two nitrogens and four carboxylate oxygens. Chemists describe EDTA as a hexadentate ligand, literally "six-toothed".

A calcium ion in water is loosely surrounded by water molecules. When it meets EDTA, the six donor atoms wrap around it and form a cage built from five-membered rings. Breaking that complex apart would require all six bonds to let go at once, which is why the complex is so much more stable than anything a single-site ligand can form. This is the chelate effect, and it explains why EDTA can pull calcium out of solid gypsum scale or iron out of an oxide layer.

Three consequences matter in practice.

The ratio is always one to one. Whether the metal carries a charge of two or three, one mole of EDTA binds one mole of metal. Every dosing calculation on this page follows from that.

The metal stays in the water. EDTA does not precipitate or remove anything; it masks the metal by converting it to a soluble, usually anionic, complex. In a boiler that complex leaves with the blowdown. In a cleaning job it leaves with the spent solvent. In a wastewater plant, as discussed later, that same solubility becomes a problem.

EDTA has preferences. It binds ferric iron, copper, nickel, lead and zinc far more tightly than calcium and magnesium. If iron and calcium are both present, the iron is served first. A dose calculated on hardness alone can be quietly consumed by trace heavy metals.

The general reaction is written:

M(n+) + Y(4-)  <-->  MY(n-4)

where Y(4-) is the fully deprotonated EDTA anion. For calcium: Ca(2+) + Y(4-) --> CaY(2-). For ferric iron: Fe(3+) + Y(4-) --> FeY(-).

One point that distinguishes EDTA from the phosphonates and polymers used elsewhere in water treatment: EDTA has no threshold effect. A phosphonate at 5 mg/L can hold back scale from water containing hundreds of mg/L of hardness by interfering with crystal growth. EDTA works strictly stoichiometrically; it controls exactly as much metal as it can bind and no more. This single fact decides where EDTA is economical (low-hardness boiler feedwater, cleaning solutions, trace metal control) and where it is not (open cooling towers running on hard make-up).


PHYSICAL AND CHEMICAL PROPERTIES

Values below are literature figures for the pure substances. Commercial material varies slightly by producer and grade; the technical data sheet (TDS) and the certificate of analysis (COA) supplied with each lot are the binding references.

EDTA ACID (CAS 60-00-4)

Appearance: White, odourless crystalline powder
Molecular weight: 292.24 g/mol
Melting behaviour: No true melting point; decomposes at roughly 220-245 °C
Solubility in water: About 0.5 g/L at 20-25 °C, rising to roughly 2 g/L at 80 °C
pH of aqueous slurry (10 g/L): About 2.5-3
Soluble in: Sodium hydroxide, potassium hydroxide, ammonia and sodium carbonate solutions (by neutralisation to the salt)
Insoluble in: Ethanol, acetone, ether and most common organic solvents
Acid dissociation constants (25 °C, approximate): pKa1 2.0, pKa2 2.7, pKa3 6.2, pKa4 10.3
Hygroscopicity: Slight; remains free-flowing when stored dry

TETRASODIUM EDTA (CAS 64-02-8 and hydrates)

Appearance (solid): White to off-white powder or granules
Appearance (liquid): Clear, colourless to pale yellow aqueous solution
Molecular weight: 380.17 g/mol (anhydrous basis)
Solubility in water: Very high; several hundred grams per litre at room temperature
pH (1% solution): About 10.5-11.5
Commercial liquid strength: Typically 38-40% by weight as Na4EDTA
Density of the commercial liquid: About 1.3 g/cm3 at 20 °C
Hygroscopicity (solid): Marked; opened bags cake if left exposed

DISODIUM EDTA DIHYDRATE (CAS 6381-92-6)

Appearance: White crystalline powder
Molecular weight: 372.24 g/mol
Solubility in water: About 100 g/L at 20 °C (roughly 10% by weight)
pH (5% solution): About 4-5
Water of crystallisation: 9.7% by weight (theoretical)

BEHAVIOUR THAT MATTERS IN WATER SYSTEMS

Volatility: Negligible. EDTA does not distil over with steam and has no odour.

Thermal stability in solution: Stable at ordinary process temperatures up to the boiling point. Hydrolytic breakdown accelerates as temperature climbs well above that. Free chelant degrades faster than chelant that is already holding a metal ion, which is one reason overdosing is discouraged in hot systems.

Reaction with oxygen and oxidants: Compatible with dilute hydrogen peroxide. Attacked over time by hypochlorite, chlorine, chlorine dioxide, ozone and permanganate; both the chelant and the oxidant are consumed. In hot boiler feedwater, dissolved oxygen degrades EDTA and the breakdown products can be corrosive, hence the insistence on feeding it only to deaerated water.

Behaviour at low pH: Below about pH 3, concentrated solutions can drop crystals of the free acid.

Attack on metals: EDTA solutions dissolve aluminium, zinc and galvanised coatings, and slowly attack copper and copper alloys, especially when oxygen is present. Carbon steel is attacked by free (uncomplexed) chelant. Storage tanks, dosing lines and injection quills must be chosen accordingly.

Light sensitivity: EDTA itself is stable to light, but the ferric-EDTA complex is broken down rapidly by sunlight. This is the main route by which EDTA disappears from clear surface waters.

Biodegradability: Not readily biodegradable in standard screening tests.



pH, STABILITY CONSTANTS AND WHY EDTA SOMETIMES "DOES NOT WORK"

Most complaints that EDTA failed in a water system trace back to pH, not to the product.

EDTA carries four acidic hydrogens and gives them up one by one as pH rises. The species that binds metals most strongly is the fully deprotonated anion, Y(4-), and it only dominates above about pH 10. Lower the pH and hydrogen ions compete with the metal for the binding sites. The stability constant printed in a handbook is therefore a best case; what counts in the field is the conditional stability constant at your working pH.

Accepted stability constants (log K, 25 °C, approximate) for the metals that matter in water treatment:

Barium (Ba2+): 7.9
Strontium (Sr2+): 8.7
Magnesium (Mg2+): 8.8
Calcium (Ca2+): 10.7
Manganese (Mn2+): 13.9
Ferrous iron (Fe2+): 14.3
Aluminium (Al3+): 16.4
Zinc (Zn2+): 16.5
Lead (Pb2+): 18.0
Nickel (Ni2+): 18.6
Copper (Cu2+): 18.8
Ferric iron (Fe3+): 25.1

Read the list this way: the larger the number, the tighter the grip and the lower the pH at which EDTA still holds on. Practical working windows follow from it.

Calcium and magnesium (hardness). Effective binding needs pH above 7 and is best between pH 9 and 12. Magnesium is held more weakly than calcium, so around pH 10 is ideal when both must be controlled. Expecting EDTA to manage hardness in an acidic cleaner is unrealistic; there the acid does the work.

Copper, zinc, nickel, lead. Held firmly from about pH 3 upward across a very wide range.

Ferric iron. The most strongly bound metal of all, complexed from pH 1-2 upward. But there is a ceiling. Above about pH 6.5-7, hydroxide ions begin to compete, and in strongly alkaline water the iron gradually leaves the chelate and precipitates as ferric hydroxide. This is why iron control in high-pH systems is usually assigned to gluconate, DTPA or dispersant polymers working alongside EDTA.

Ferrous iron and manganese. Bound satisfactorily from about pH 5 upward. In boiler chemical cleaning, keeping dissolved iron in the ferrous state under reducing, alkaline conditions is precisely what allows ammoniated EDTA to carry large iron loads at pH 9.

Barium and strontium. Bound only weakly. EDTA will dissolve calcium sulfate readily, strontium sulfate slowly and barium sulfate poorly; barite scale normally calls for DTPA-based dissolvers at high pH.

Competition is the other trap. When EDTA is dosed as a plain "hardness treatment", any copper or iron in the water takes its share first. A proper water analysis for an EDTA application reports iron, manganese and copper as well as total hardness.


EDTA DOSAGE CALCULATION FOR WATER TREATMENT

How much EDTA is needed per ppm of hardness? Because the binding ratio is fixed, the answer is pure arithmetic.

CHELATION VALUE BY PRODUCT FORM

Chelation value expresses how much calcium one gram of product can bind, stated as calcium carbonate (mg CaCO3 per g). Theoretical values:

EDTA acid (292.24 g/mol): 342 mg CaCO3/g
Disodium EDTA dihydrate (372.24 g/mol): 269 mg CaCO3/g
Tetrasodium EDTA, anhydrous (380.17 g/mol): 263 mg CaCO3/g
Tetrasodium EDTA tetrahydrate (452.23 g/mol): 221 mg CaCO3/g
Tetrasodium EDTA 39% solution: about 103 mg CaCO3/g

Two powders both sold as "tetrasodium EDTA" can differ by about 16% in active content depending on whether the assay is quoted on the anhydrous or the tetrahydrate basis. Comparing offers on cost per kilogram of calcium carbonate bound, rather than cost per kilogram of product, shows the real picture.

DOSING FACTORS PER UNIT OF HARDNESS

To chelate 1 mg/L (1 ppm) of hardness expressed as CaCO3:

Tetrasodium EDTA, 100% anhydrous basis: 3.80 mg/L
Tetrasodium EDTA 39% liquid: 9.7 mg/L
Tetrasodium EDTA 38% liquid: 10.0 mg/L
Disodium EDTA dihydrate: 3.72 mg/L
EDTA acid: 2.92 mg/L

The familiar rule of thumb, "ten parts of liquid chelant per part of hardness", comes straight from the 38% line above.

In other hardness units:

1 grain per US gallon (gpg) = 17.1 mg/L CaCO3, requiring about 65 mg/L of anhydrous Na4EDTA.
1 French degree (°fH) = 10 mg/L CaCO3, requiring about 38 mg/L.
1 German degree (°dH) = 17.8 mg/L CaCO3, requiring about 68 mg/L.
1 English (Clark) degree = 14.3 mg/L CaCO3, requiring about 54 mg/L.

In US customary units: each ppm of hardness requires about 0.032 lb of anhydrous Na4EDTA per 1,000 US gallons, or about 0.083 lb of 38% liquid.

DOSING FACTORS PER UNIT OF METAL

Theoretical anhydrous tetrasodium EDTA required to bind 1 mg/L of each metal (as the metal):

Calcium: 9.5 mg/L
Magnesium: 15.6 mg/L
Iron: 6.8 mg/L
Manganese: 6.9 mg/L
Copper: 6.0 mg/L
Zinc: 5.8 mg/L

Multiply by 0.77 for the equivalent quantity of EDTA acid, or divide by 0.39 for 39% liquid.
 

GENERAL FORMULAS

Na4EDTA demand (mg/L, 100% basis) = [Hardness as CaCO3 x 3.80] + [Fe x 6.8] + [Cu x 6.0] + [Mn x 6.9] + desired free residual

Liquid product demand (mg/L) = Na4EDTA demand (100% basis) / product strength as a decimal

Daily consumption (kg/day) = Liquid product demand (mg/L) x treated flow (m3/day) / 1,000

WORKED EXAMPLE 1: BOILER FEEDWATER

A softened and deaerated feedwater contains 0.5 mg/L total hardness as CaCO3 and 0.05 mg/L iron. Feedwater flow is 20 m3/h.

Hardness demand: 0.5 x 3.80 = 1.90 mg/L
Iron demand: 0.05 x 6.8 = 0.34 mg/L
Total stoichiometric demand: 2.24 mg/L as Na4EDTA (100%)
As 39% liquid: 2.24 / 0.39 = 5.7 mg/L
Hourly feed: 5.7 x 20 = about 115 g/h of liquid product, before any allowance for residual

The modest size of that number is the point. A chelant programme is affordable when the softener works. If softener leakage lets hardness rise to 5 mg/L, demand jumps tenfold, and either the chelant bill or the boiler tubes pay for it.

WORKED EXAMPLE 2: BATCH MAKE-UP FOR A CLEANING OR PROCESS BATH

A 2 m3 bath is made up with water of 150 mg/L hardness (15 °fH).

Na4EDTA needed: 150 x 3.80 x 2 = 1,140 g anhydrous basis, or about 2.9 kg of 39% liquid.

Field practice adds 10-20% for metals introduced by the soil being removed. The same bath made up with softened water needs roughly a tenth of that, which is usually the cheapest way to cut chelant cost.



SCALE-DISSOLVING CAPACITY: HOW MUCH DEPOSIT CAN EDTA REMOVE?

For cleaning work the question is reversed: how much scale will a given charge of EDTA dissolve? Theoretical capacities, again from the 1:1 ratio:

Deposit / kg dissolved per kg anhydrous Na4EDTA / kg of 39% liquid needed per kg of deposit

Calcium carbonate (calcite, CaCO3): 0.26 / 9.7
Calcium sulfate, anhydrite (CaSO4): 0.36 / 7.2
Calcium sulfate dihydrate (gypsum): 0.45 / 5.7
Calcium phosphate (hydroxyapatite): 0.26 / 9.7
Magnesium hydroxide (brucite): 0.15 / 16.7
Magnetite (Fe3O4): 0.20 / 12.6
Hematite (Fe2O3): 0.21 / 12.2
Copper oxide (CuO): 0.21 / 12.3
Strontium sulfate (celestite): 0.48 / 5.3 (theoretical; slow in practice)
Barium sulfate (barite): 0.61 / 4.2 (theoretical; poorly achieved with EDTA)

These are ceilings. Real jobs reach them only if contact time, temperature, pH and circulation are adequate, and dense or aged deposits dissolve far more slowly than fresh ones. A sensible planning approach is to estimate the deposit weight, calculate the theoretical chelant charge, add a margin of 10-25%, and then track free chelant during the clean so that a top-up can be made before the solvent is exhausted.

Why choose EDTA over acid for descaling? Mineral acids are faster and cheaper per kilogram of carbonate removed. EDTA earns its place where acid cannot be used or does a poor job: sulfate scales that acids barely touch, equipment with acid-sensitive metallurgy, membranes with pH limits, systems where chloride from hydrochloric acid is unacceptable, and jobs where the hazard and waste handling of strong acid outweigh the longer cleaning time. EDTA also dissolves scale without releasing carbon dioxide gas, which matters in closed circuits and membrane housings.


HOW EDTA IS MANUFACTURED

EDTA was first made in Germany in the mid-1930s by Ferdinand Munz, who was looking for a stronger substitute for citric acid to control water hardness in textile dyehouses. It has, in other words, been a water treatment chemical from the day it was invented. Three production routes are worth knowing.

1) The chloroacetic acid route (Munz synthesis)

Ethylenediamine is reacted with monochloroacetic acid in the presence of sodium hydroxide. The product is tetrasodium EDTA, but an equivalent amount of sodium chloride forms alongside it and is costly to remove. The route has been abandoned commercially.

2) Single-stage alkaline cyanomethylation (Bersworth process)

This is the dominant industrial method. Ethylenediamine, formaldehyde and sodium cyanide react together in strongly alkaline aqueous solution. The nitrile intermediates hydrolyse in the same reactor, tetrasodium EDTA solution is obtained directly, and ammonia is driven off.

Overall reaction:

H2N-CH2-CH2-NH2 + 4 CH2O + 4 NaCN + 4 H2O --> Na4EDTA + 4 NH3

Most of the ammonia is stripped and recovered. A small portion reacts with formaldehyde and cyanide to form the sodium salt of nitrilotriacetic acid (NTA). That is the origin of the NTA found as an impurity in technical-grade tetrasodium EDTA solutions, and the reason specifications carry a separate NTA limit.

3) Two-stage Singer process

Preferred where high purity is required. In the first stage, ethylenediamine, formaldehyde and hydrogen cyanide react under acidic conditions to give a water-insoluble solid intermediate, ethylenediaminetetraacetonitrile (EDTN). The solid is filtered and washed, then hydrolysed with sodium hydroxide in a separate stage. Because the intermediate is isolated and washed, ammonia-driven side reactions are suppressed and the product contains very little NTA.

From the sodium salt to the rest of the family

Both modern processes deliver tetrasodium EDTA solution first. The other forms derive from it.

EDTA acid: the tetrasodium solution is acidified with sulfuric or hydrochloric acid to below pH 2. The sparingly soluble acid crystallises, is filtered, washed and dried. The step also purifies the product, since NTA and inorganic salts stay in the mother liquor.

Disodium EDTA: EDTA acid is neutralised with two equivalents of sodium hydroxide and crystallised as the dihydrate.

Tetrasodium EDTA powder: the solution is spray-dried or crystallised.

Ammonium EDTA solutions: EDTA acid is dissolved in aqueous ammonia to the required pH.

What this means for a buyer: two "EDTA 4Na 39% liquid" products can look identical on paper yet differ in NTA content, colour, free alkalinity and iron, depending on process and purification. For routine boiler and cleaning duty those differences rarely matter. For membrane cleaning in pharmaceutical or food plants, or for blending into products with tight specifications, they can.


FORMS AND GRADES USED IN WATER TREATMENT: WHICH ONE DO YOU NEED?

Tetrasodium EDTA liquid, 38-40%
The workhorse. It pumps easily, needs no dissolving, generates no dust and is already at the alkaline pH most boiler and cleaning applications require. Choose it for continuous chemical feed, for blending liquid boiler and cleaning formulations, and wherever automatic dosing is used.

Tetrasodium EDTA powder or granules
Roughly two to two and a half times the active content of the liquid per kilogram shipped. Choose it for long transport distances, limited storage volume, powder blends and membrane cleaning chemicals sold as solids. It must be kept dry.

EDTA acid
The most concentrated form and the only sodium-free one. It is the raw material for ammonium EDTA cleaning solvents, potassium salts and custom blends. One kilogram of EDTA acid needs, in theory, 0.55 kg of pure sodium hydroxide to convert it to the tetrasodium salt and yields the equivalent of about 1.30 kg of anhydrous Na4EDTA.

Disodium EDTA
Mildly acidic in solution, with limited solubility. In water treatment it is used mainly for laboratory titrants, near-neutral cleaning formulations and products where the alkalinity of the tetrasodium salt is unwanted.

Diammonium and tetraammonium EDTA
Specialist solvents for pre-operational and operational chemical cleaning of boilers, heat recovery steam generators and heat exchangers. Ammonia provides the alkalinity without adding sodium, and it volatilises during the subsequent boil-out or drain.

Quick selection guide

Continuous boiler chelant feed: tetrasodium EDTA liquid.
Formulating a liquid boiler treatment with polymer: tetrasodium EDTA liquid.
RO or NF alkaline cleaning: tetrasodium EDTA, powder or liquid, with sodium hydroxide.
Utility boiler or HRSG iron oxide removal: ammoniated EDTA prepared from EDTA acid.
Descaling a gypsum-fouled exchanger: tetrasodium EDTA at alkaline pH.
Hardness titrant for the plant laboratory: analytical-grade disodium EDTA dihydrate.
Sodium must be avoided: EDTA acid neutralised with potassium hydroxide or ammonia.



EDTA APPLICATIONS IN WATER TREATMENT

The sections that follow go application by application. Each one states the problem EDTA solves, the form normally used, the operating limits to respect and the situations in which another chemistry is the better answer.


1. Boiler water treatment: the chelant programme

The problem. Even well-softened feedwater carries a fraction of a milligram per litre of hardness into the boiler. At boiler temperature calcium and magnesium salts become less soluble, not more, and they deposit on the hottest surfaces. A thin layer of scale insulates the tube, raises metal temperature, wastes fuel and eventually causes tube failure.

Two philosophies deal with it. A phosphate programme deliberately precipitates the hardness as a soft sludge and relies on blowdown to remove it. A chelant programme does the opposite: it keeps the hardness dissolved as the EDTA complex so that there is nothing to settle, and the complex leaves with the continuous blowdown. Run well, a chelant programme gives noticeably cleaner heat transfer surfaces and less sludge to manage. That is what people mean when they search for EDTA boiler treatment, boiler chelant or solubilising programme.

Form used. Tetrasodium EDTA solution, either neat or formulated with dispersant polymers. Many modern products are chelant/polymer blends, in which the polymer handles iron oxide and any hardness the chelant does not cover.

Where it fits. Chelant programmes are intended for boilers with consistently good feedwater: softened or demineralised make-up, high condensate return, hardness reliably in the low single digits of mg/L or below. Industry guidance generally restricts EDTA programmes to low and medium pressure units, commonly quoted as up to about 1,000-1,200 psig (roughly 70-83 bar), because the chelant hydrolyses increasingly quickly at higher saturation temperatures.

The rules that keep a chelant programme safe:

Feed only to deaerated water. Dissolved oxygen degrades EDTA at feedwater temperature and the combination is corrosive. The chelant goes in after the deaerator and after the oxygen scavenger has had time to react.

Feed continuously and in proportion to feedwater flow. Slug feeding produces alternating starvation and excess.

Use a stainless steel injection quill that delivers the chemical into the centre of the feedwater line, downstream of the feed pump. Concentrated chelant running along a carbon steel pipe wall will thin it.

Keep copper alloys out of the picture where possible. Chelant fed ahead of copper-bearing feedwater heaters can strip copper and carry it into the boiler.

Control the free residual tightly. The usual target is a small free chelant residual in the boiler water, of the order of a few mg/L, and many operators prefer to run slightly under the stoichiometric demand and let polymer cover the gap. Sustained excess of free chelant attacks the protective magnetite layer and the steel beneath it, producing the smooth, localised metal loss sometimes called chelant corrosion or chelant gouging, typically in high-velocity areas such as steam drum internals and tube entrances.

Test what you are controlling. Free chelant is measured by titration with a standard metal solution; total chelant requires breaking the existing complexes first. Hardness and iron in the feedwater should be logged alongside the residual, because a rising demand is often the first sign of softener leakage or condensate contamination.

A limitation to state plainly: at boiler water pH, EDTA does not hold ferric iron well, because hydroxide competes too successfully. Iron oxide transport in a chelant programme depends largely on the companion polymer. EDTA is also not an oxygen scavenger, an alkalinity builder or a condensate treatment; it is one component of a programme, never the whole of it.

When to choose something else. Feedwater hardness that swings widely, units above the pressure range noted above, systems with poor deaeration, and plants without the monitoring discipline a chelant requires are better served by phosphate/polymer or all-polymer programmes.
 
 
2. Chemical cleaning of boilers, HRSGs and steam generators

New boilers arrive with mill scale and construction debris; operating boilers accumulate magnetite, copper and hardness deposits on the waterside. Both are removed by chemical cleaning, and ammoniated EDTA has become one of the standard solvents for the job, particularly for drum boilers and heat recovery steam generators.

How the process runs, in outline. A solution of tetraammonium EDTA, commonly around 5% and adjusted to about pH 9-9.5, is circulated together with a corrosion inhibitor. The unit is warmed, often by light firing, to a solvent temperature in the region of 120-140 °C (roughly 250-280 °F). Operators stay below about 150 °C (300 °F), where decomposition of the chelant becomes significant. Under these alkaline, reducing conditions iron oxides dissolve and the iron is held as the ferrous chelate. Iron concentration and free EDTA are tracked by analysis until iron levels off with free chelant still in hand, which usually takes from half a day to a day and a half.

If copper is present, the solution is then cooled to roughly 65 °C (150 °F) and an oxidant, air, oxygen or sodium nitrite, is introduced. The oxidant converts ferrous chelate to ferric chelate, which in turn oxidises metallic copper so that the EDTA can take it into solution. The same oxidising stage leaves the cleaned steel passivated. Iron removal, copper removal and passivation are thus achieved with a single fill of solvent, which is a major practical advantage over multi-stage acid cleaning.

Why plants choose it. The solvent is alkaline and far less aggressive to the base metal than hydrochloric acid. It introduces no chloride, an important consideration for austenitic stainless steels. One solution handles both iron and copper. Waste volume is lower because there is one stage instead of several.

What it costs. Time, chiefly: an EDTA iron stage takes considerably longer than an inhibited hydrochloric acid stage. The chemical cost per kilogram of deposit removed is higher, and good circulation through every circuit is essential because the solvent works by contact, not by violent reaction.

Diammonium EDTA, at mildly acidic pH, is used in a related lower-temperature process when firing the unit is not possible. Chemical cleaning of pressure parts is specialist work; solvent selection, inhibitor choice and procedure belong with a qualified cleaning contractor and the boiler manufacturer's guidance.

Rough sizing from the capacity table: every kilogram of magnetite to be removed needs, in theory, about 3.8 kg of EDTA acid equivalent. A 100 m3 system filled with 5% solution as EDTA acid (5,000 kg) can therefore hold about 1,300 kg of dissolved magnetite before the chelant is spent.
 
 
3. Reverse osmosis and nanofiltration membrane cleaning

Membranes foul in recognisable patterns: carbonate and sulfate scale at the tail end of the plant where the concentrate is most saturated, biofilm and organic matter at the front. Acid cleaning deals with carbonates and metal hydroxides. Sulfate scales, biofilm and organics respond to high-pH cleaning, and this is where EDTA is used.

The reference recipe. Membrane manufacturers' cleaning guides list a solution of about 1.0% tetrasodium EDTA with 0.1% sodium hydroxide, at around pH 12, as a preferred cleaner for sulfate scale and as an effective cleaner for inorganic colloids, biofilm and organic fouling on polyamide thin-film composite elements. Another widely published manufacturer formulation combines about 0.8% sodium EDTA with 2% sodium tripolyphosphate at pH 10 for calcium sulfate scale with light organic fouling.

What EDTA contributes. It dissolves calcium sulfate directly. It also extracts the calcium that cross-links biofilm polymers and natural organic matter into a coherent gel; once the calcium is gone the fouling layer loosens and the caustic and surfactant can lift it.

Limits to respect. Maximum temperature at high pH is set by the element manufacturer and is typically in the 30-40 °C range for pH 12; exceeding the published pH and temperature envelope hydrolyses the membrane. Cleaning solutions are made up with permeate or deionised water. A typical procedure circulates the solution at low pressure, allows a soak (from one hour to overnight for stubborn sulfate scale), circulates again at higher flow and then flushes thoroughly.

What EDTA will not remove. Silica scale and barium sulfate are barely touched. Heavy iron fouling is better addressed with an acidic or reducing cleaner. Diagnosing the foulant first saves both chemical and membrane life.

The same chemistry applies to ultrafiltration and microfiltration systems, within the pH limits of the membrane material, and to cleaning electrodeionisation stacks where the manufacturer permits it.


4. Heat exchangers, evaporators and thermal desalination

Plate and shell-and-tube exchangers, falling film evaporators, brine heaters in multi-stage flash and multiple-effect distillation plants, and sugar and dairy evaporators all suffer from calcium sulfate and mixed calcium scales. Circulating a 4-10% tetrasodium EDTA solution at pH 9-11 and 50-70 °C dissolves these deposits without the corrosion allowance that acid cleaning demands. Titanium, stainless steel and most elastomers tolerate the solution well. Cleaning progress is followed by measuring free EDTA and dissolved calcium; the job is finished when calcium stops rising while free chelant remains.


5. Cooling water systems and closed loops

Open recirculating cooling towers are the one major area of water treatment where EDTA is rarely the scale inhibitor of choice. The make-up is usually hard, the cycles of concentration multiply that hardness several times, and stoichiometric chelation of it all would cost many times more than a few mg/L of phosphonate and polymer. EDTA would also dissolve galvanised tower components and accelerate attack on copper alloy condenser tubes.

EDTA does have a place around cooling systems, however:

Off-line and on-line cleaning of scaled condensers and exchangers, where a neutral to alkaline chelant clean is preferred to acid.
Pre-commissioning cleaning and flushing of closed chilled and heating water loops, to remove mill scale, flux residues and iron oxide before inhibitor is added.
Remedial cleaning of closed loops fouled with iron oxide sludge.
Rust and scale removal in engine cooling circuits and process jackets.

In all of these, the system should be flushed and re-inhibited promptly after cleaning, since a chelant-cleaned steel surface is active and will flash rust.


6. Industrial process water: conditioning at the point of use

Not every plant can soften or demineralise all of its water, and even softened water carries traces of iron, copper and manganese picked up from pipework. EDTA added at the point of use conditions the water for the process that follows.

Textile wet processing. Hardness precipitates soaps and dyes; iron and copper decompose hydrogen peroxide during bleaching and cause catalytic damage to cotton. Typical additions are 0.5-2 g/L of chelant in the bath.

Pulp and paper. Manganese, iron and copper entering with the wood are chelated and washed out ahead of peroxide bleaching stages, which cuts peroxide consumption and improves brightness. Typical use is 1-4 kg per tonne of oven-dry pulp.

Commercial and industrial laundries. EDTA softens wash water, prevents greying from calcium soaps and stops iron staining where the supply is iron-bearing.

Food and beverage cleaning-in-place. Caustic CIP detergents built with tetrasodium EDTA remove milkstone and beerstone in one alkaline step, often reducing the need for a separate acid wash.

Bottle washing. EDTA in the caustic soak keeps hardness from depositing on bottles and machine internals and helps dissolve aluminium foil and label residues.

Emulsion polymerisation and chemical synthesis. Trace metals in process water change reaction rates from batch to batch; a few mg/L of EDTA makes the water behave the same way every time.

Metal finishing rinses and alkaline cleaners. EDTA prevents hardness films on cleaned parts and keeps dissolved metals from redepositing.

The common thread is that EDTA makes the performance of the downstream chemistry independent of variations in the water supply.


7. Wastewater: where EDTA is the problem to be solved

An honest account of EDTA in water treatment has to include the other side. The property that makes EDTA valuable in a process, holding metals in solution across a wide pH range, makes it troublesome in the effluent plant. Conventional heavy metal removal raises the pH so that metals precipitate as hydroxides. Copper, nickel, zinc or lead bound to EDTA will not precipitate that way, and the discharge fails its metal limits even though the treatment plant is operating exactly as designed. Electroless copper and nickel plating, printed circuit board manufacture, metal cleaning and some textile and photographic operations are the usual sources.

Established ways of dealing with EDTA-complexed metals:

Segregation. Keep chelant-bearing streams separate from general rinse waters so that a small volume receives special treatment and the bulk remains easy to treat.

Displacement followed by precipitation. Adding an excess of a competing cation, typically ferric iron or calcium with lime at high pH, pushes the heavy metal out of the chelate so that it can precipitate.

Sulfide or organosulfide precipitation. Metal sulfides and dithiocarbamate precipitates are insoluble enough to pull copper and other metals away from EDTA.

Oxidative destruction. Fenton chemistry, ozone, UV-peroxide and electrochemical oxidation break the EDTA molecule itself, after which normal hydroxide precipitation works.

Reductive or electrolytic recovery. Copper can be plated out or cemented from concentrated spent baths.

Recovery of the chelant. Acidifying a concentrated spent solution to below pH 2 crystallises EDTA acid, which can be filtered off and in some operations reused.

Designers of treatment plants should be told at the outset that EDTA is present; retrofitting a decomplexation step is far more expensive than planning for one. Users, for their part, reduce the downstream burden by dosing to calculated demand instead of by habit.


8. Drinking water: guideline values and what they mean

EDTA is not a drinking water treatment chemical, and nothing on this page should be read as suggesting it be added to potable supplies. It is relevant to potable water in two ways.

First, as a trace contaminant. Because EDTA is used widely and biodegrades slowly, low concentrations are found in rivers that receive treated effluent and, at lower levels still, in drinking water drawn from them. The World Health Organization's Guidelines for Drinking-water Quality set a guideline value of 600 micrograms per litre (0.6 mg/L, expressed as the free acid). The value is derived from the acceptable daily intake of 1.9 mg per kg of body weight established by the Joint FAO/WHO Expert Committee on Food Additives, with only 1% of that intake allocated to drinking water because of EDTA's permitted use in food. Concentrations reported in surface waters and in drinking water prepared from them are generally in the range of a few to a few tens of micrograms per litre, well below the guideline. The WHO background document notes that conventional drinking water treatment, including activated carbon, removes very little EDTA, and that ozonation is the most effective removal step. Individual countries may set their own values.

Second, as a tool for the people who run waterworks. Hardness, one of the most frequently measured drinking water parameters, is determined by EDTA titration, and EDTA-based cleaners are used on the membranes of desalination and water reuse plants, after which the elements are flushed before returning to service.


9. Water analysis: the EDTA hardness titration

Anyone searching for how to measure water hardness will arrive at EDTA. The EDTA titrimetric method appears in Standard Methods for the Examination of Water and Wastewater as Method 2340 C and in ASTM D1126, and it is the basis of most hardness test kits.

Principle. The sample is buffered to pH 10.0 (plus or minus 0.1) with an ammonia buffer, and an indicator, Eriochrome Black T or Calmagite, is added. The indicator forms a wine-red complex with magnesium. Standard EDTA solution is added from a burette; it binds calcium first, then magnesium, and when the last of the magnesium is taken from the indicator the colour turns sharply from red to blue.

Calculation.

Total hardness (mg/L as CaCO3) = [Titrant volume (mL) x EDTA molarity x 100,090] / Sample volume (mL)

With 0.01 M EDTA, each millilitre of titrant corresponds to 1.00 mg of CaCO3. Example: a 50 mL sample that consumes 7.5 mL of 0.01 M EDTA has a hardness of (7.5 x 0.01 x 100,090) / 50 = about 150 mg/L as CaCO3, which is 15 °fH or 8.8 gpg.

Practical points. Complete the titration within about five minutes of adding the buffer to avoid calcium carbonate precipitation. Iron, copper, manganese and other heavy metals interfere by blocking the indicator or fading the endpoint; inhibitors are added when they are present. Calcium hardness alone is determined in a separate titration at pH 12-13, where magnesium precipitates as the hydroxide and a calcium-specific indicator is used; magnesium hardness is obtained by difference.

The reverse titration, standard calcium or zinc solution added to a sample containing EDTA, is how free chelant residual is checked in boiler water and how the strength of a cleaning solution is followed during a job.
 
 
10. Oilfield water, geothermal brines and injection systems

Produced water and injection water systems scale with calcium carbonate, calcium sulfate, strontium sulfate and barium sulfate, and they carry dissolved iron. EDTA-based dissolvers remove calcium carbonate and calcium sulfate deposits from tubing, flowlines and surface equipment where acid is undesirable on account of corrosion, sludge formation or high bottom-hole temperature. In acidising operations, EDTA is added for iron control: it keeps ferric iron from reprecipitating as a gelatinous hydroxide as the acid spends and the pH rises. Barium sulfate, as noted earlier, is the exception; it calls for DTPA-based formulations at high pH. In steam-flood operations, chelants form part of the treatment for once-through steam generator feedwater.


11. Swimming pools, spas and decorative water features

Metal sequestrants are sold to pool owners to prevent brown, green and black staining from iron, copper and manganese, and EDTA appears in some of them. It binds these metals very effectively, but pool water is chlorinated, and chlorine steadily oxidises EDTA. Protection is therefore temporary, and sequestrant demand is continuous. Phosphonate-based sequestrants resist chlorine better and are more common for routine maintenance; EDTA-type products are more often used for one-off stain treatment or start-up of a freshly filled pool with metal-bearing water.


12. Odour control, gas scrubbing and advanced oxidation

Chelated iron has uses that go beyond holding a metal in solution. In liquid redox scrubbers, ferric chelate oxidises hydrogen sulfide from biogas, sewer air or sour gas to elemental sulfur, and is then regenerated with air; EDTA and related chelants keep the iron dissolved through the cycle. In advanced oxidation research and in some full-scale applications, iron chelates allow Fenton-type oxidation to operate at near-neutral pH, where unchelated iron would precipitate. These are specialist processes in which chelant degradation by the oxidant must be factored into the operating cost.



INDUSTRIES THAT USE EDTA FOR WATER-RELATED DUTIES

Readers often want to know whether EDTA is used in their own sector. The list below maps industries to the water treatment duties described above.

Power generation: chemical cleaning of drum boilers and heat recovery steam generators; condenser cleaning; demineralisation plant and membrane cleaning.

Industrial steam users (food, chemical, textile, paper, rubber, laundries, hospitals, district heating): boiler chelant and chelant/polymer programmes; closed loop cleaning.

Desalination and water reuse: reverse osmosis and nanofiltration membrane cleaning; evaporator descaling in thermal plants.

Municipal water and wastewater utilities: laboratory hardness analysis; membrane clean-in-place; iron chelate odour control.

Oil, gas and petrochemicals: scale dissolvers, iron control, steam generator feedwater treatment, exchanger cleaning.

Food, dairy, brewing and beverage: alkaline CIP detergents, bottle washing, evaporator cleaning, membrane cleaning in whey and juice processing.

Textile, leather and dyeing: process water conditioning, peroxide bleach stabilisation.

Pulp and paper: metal management ahead of peroxide and dithionite bleaching.

Metal finishing and electronics: alkaline cleaners, electroless plating baths, and the associated wastewater treatment.

HVAC and building services: pre-commission cleaning of chilled and heating water circuits.

Marine and offshore: evaporator and cooler descaling, boiler treatment on board.

Water treatment service companies and chemical blenders: formulation of boiler treatments, membrane cleaners, descalers and specialty cleaning compounds.



EDTA FORMULATIONS FOR WATER TREATMENT: STARTING-POINT RECIPES

The recipes below are frameworks for development work, not finished products. Percentages are by weight unless stated. Raw material strength, water quality, metallurgy and local regulations all change the final formula, and anything intended for pressure equipment or membranes must be checked against the equipment manufacturer's limits before use.

FORMULATION 1 - Liquid boiler treatment, chelant/polymer type

Tetrasodium EDTA solution (39%): 30-50
Dispersant polymer (polyacrylate or acrylic copolymer, as supplied): 5-10
Sodium hydroxide (50%): to pH above 11
Softened or deionised water: to 100

How it is used: fed continuously to deaerated feedwater in proportion to flow, with the dose set from measured feedwater hardness and iron using the factors given earlier. The polymer disperses iron oxide and covers hardness excursions. Formulator's note: keep catalysed sulfite out of this blend and out of the same dosing tank. EDTA binds the cobalt catalyst and slows the oxygen scavenging reaction, so chelant and catalysed sulfite are fed from separate tanks to separate points.

FORMULATION 2 - High-pH cleaning solution for RO and NF membranes (in-use strength)

Tetrasodium EDTA: 1.0
Sodium hydroxide: 0.1 (to about pH 12)
RO permeate or deionised water: to 100

For 1,000 litres of cleaning solution: 10 kg of tetrasodium EDTA powder (or about 25.6 kg of 39% liquid) and 1 kg of sodium hydroxide. This follows the composition published in membrane manufacturers' cleaning guides for sulfate scale, biofilm and organic fouling. Observe the element manufacturer's maximum pH and temperature. Capacity check: 10 kg of Na4EDTA can dissolve at most about 4.5 kg of gypsum, so heavily scaled systems need the solution renewed or the scale load split across several batches.

FORMULATION 3 - Calcium sulfate scale cleaner for membranes, moderate pH (in-use strength)

Sodium tripolyphosphate: 2.0
Sodium EDTA: 0.8
pH: adjusted to about 10
Permeate: to 100

A long-established alternative from membrane manufacturer literature, useful where pH 12 is not permitted for the element in question.

FORMULATION 4 - Descaling solution for heat exchangers and evaporators (in-use strength)

Tetrasodium EDTA: 4-10, sized from the estimated deposit weight
Low-foam non-ionic wetting agent: 0.05-0.1
pH: 9-11 (adjust with sodium hydroxide if required)
Temperature: 50-70 °C
Method: closed-loop circulation with periodic analysis of free EDTA and dissolved calcium

Sizing rule: 1 kg of calcium carbonate requires about 3.8 kg of anhydrous Na4EDTA; 1 kg of gypsum about 2.2 kg. Add 10-25% margin. Circulate until calcium stops rising with free chelant still present.

FORMULATION 5 - Near-neutral iron oxide remover for closed loops and small circuits (in-use strength)

EDTA, as a sodium or ammonium salt: 2-5
Citric acid or ammonia: to pH 5-7
Corrosion inhibitor suitable for the metals present: as recommended by its supplier
Copper inhibitor (azole type) where copper alloys are present: as recommended
Temperature: 50-60 °C

The mildly acidic to neutral pH keeps ferric iron within the range where EDTA holds it. After cleaning, the circuit is drained, flushed until the rinse is clear and immediately passivated or dosed with its normal corrosion inhibitor.

FORMULATION 6 - Ammoniated EDTA solvent for boiler chemical cleaning (in-use strength)

EDTA acid: about 5 (range adjusted to the iron load)
Aqueous ammonia: to pH 9.0-9.5
Corrosion inhibitor qualified for ammoniated EDTA service: per supplier
Demineralised water: to 100

Converting EDTA acid fully to the tetraammonium salt takes, in theory, about 0.23 kg of ammonia (as NH3) per kilogram of acid; the actual quantity is set by the target pH. This is the solvent described in the boiler cleaning section, and it is included here so that purchasing teams can see why chemical cleaning contractors buy EDTA acid in bulk. Design and execution of the cleaning itself is contractor work.

FORMULATION 7 - Alkaline CIP concentrate for food, dairy and beverage plants

Sodium hydroxide solution (48-50%): 40-50
Tetrasodium EDTA solution (39%): 10-20
Sodium gluconate: 2-4
Alkali-stable low-foam wetting agent: 0.5-1
Soft water: to 100

Used at 1-3% in the wash, 60-80 °C. EDTA dissolves calcium-based soils; gluconate controls iron and aluminium at high alkalinity. Do not combine with hypochlorite in the same tank.

FORMULATION 8 - Additive for caustic bottle-washing solutions

Tetrasodium EDTA solution (39%): 40-60
Sodium gluconate: 10-15
Phosphonate scale inhibitor: 2-5
Defoamer: as required
Water: to 100

Dosed at roughly 0.1-0.5% into the caustic soak, depending on water hardness and carry-over.

FORMULATION 9 - Preparing 39% tetrasodium EDTA solution from EDTA acid (per 100 kg)

EDTA acid: 30.0 kg
Sodium hydroxide solution (50%): 32.8 kg
Water: 37.2 kg

Add the acid gradually to the diluted caustic with stirring; the neutralisation releases heat. The result is 100 kg of solution containing 39 kg of Na4EDTA. This route suits users who already handle bulk caustic and want to minimise freight on water.



LABORATORY SOLUTIONS FOR THE WATER TREATMENT CHEMIST

0.01 M EDTA titrant (1 litre)
Dissolve 3.722 g of analytical-grade disodium EDTA dihydrate in deionised water and make up to 1,000 mL in a volumetric flask. Standardise against primary-standard calcium carbonate solution. 1 mL = 1.00 mg CaCO3.

pH 10 hardness buffer (250 mL)
Dissolve 16.9 g of ammonium chloride in 143 mL of concentrated ammonium hydroxide, add 1.25 g of the magnesium salt of EDTA and dilute to 250 mL with deionised water. The magnesium-EDTA ensures a sharp endpoint in samples that contain little magnesium. Keep tightly stoppered and discard when 1-2 mL no longer brings a sample to pH 10.

0.5 M EDTA stock, pH 8.0 (1 litre)
Add 186.1 g of disodium EDTA dihydrate to about 800 mL of water. It will not dissolve at first. Stir while adding sodium hydroxide (about 20 g of pellets, or the equivalent as solution) until the pH reaches 8.0, at which point the solution clears. Make up to 1 litre. The common mistake is waiting for the solid to dissolve before adjusting pH: the solubility limit of the disodium salt is only about 0.26 M.

Standard calcium solution for free chelant titration (1.000 g/L as CaCO3)
Dissolve 1.000 g of dried primary-standard calcium carbonate in the minimum of dilute hydrochloric acid, boil briefly to expel carbon dioxide, cool and dilute to 1,000 mL.

Storage tip: EDTA solutions slowly leach calcium and other metals from soft glass. Keep standard solutions in polyethylene or polypropylene bottles.



COMPATIBILITY NOTES FOR FORMULATORS AND OPERATORS

Oxidising biocides. Sodium hypochlorite, chlorine, bromine, chlorine dioxide and ozone all oxidise EDTA. Chelant and oxidant are both lost. Do not co-formulate them, and allow for the extra oxidant demand if EDTA enters a chlorinated system.

Non-oxidising biocides. Generally compatible. EDTA often improves their performance against Gram-negative bacteria and biofilm by removing the calcium and magnesium that stabilise cell walls and biofilm matrices.

Oxygen scavengers. Compatible with uncatalysed sulfite in the boiler; incompatible with cobalt-catalysed sulfite in the same tank, as explained above.

Phosphates and phosphonates. Compatible, and frequently combined. In a boiler, calcium is taken by the chelant in preference to phosphate; when the chelant is exhausted, phosphate takes over as a backstop.

Polymers. Anionic dispersants are fully compatible. Cationic polymers and quaternary ammonium compounds can form haze or precipitate with the EDTA anion at higher concentrations; test first.

Corrosion inhibitors. EDTA can strip the protective films formed by zinc, phosphate and azole programmes. After any chelant cleaning, re-establish the inhibitor film before returning the system to service. Add silicate when cleaning solutions will contact aluminium.

pH adjustment. Tetrasodium EDTA raises pH; disodium EDTA lowers it slightly. Complexing a metal releases hydrogen ions from partly protonated EDTA, so heavily loaded solutions drift acid.

Materials of construction. Suitable: stainless steel 304 and 316, high-density polyethylene, polypropylene, PVC, glass-reinforced plastic, EPDM and most common elastomers. Unsuitable for prolonged contact with concentrated solutions: aluminium, zinc and galvanised steel, copper, brass and bronze, and unlined carbon steel.

Dissolving the powder. Add tetrasodium EDTA powder to water gradually with agitation; dissolution is exothermic. Disodium EDTA dissolves slowly in cold water; warm water speeds it up.


TROUBLESHOOTING: SYMPTOM, LIKELY CAUSE, REMEDY

Symptom: Boiler tubes still scale although chelant is being fed.
Likely cause: Feedwater hardness exceeds the stoichiometric dose, usually through softener leakage or condensate contamination; or the chelant is being degraded by oxygen before it reaches the boiler.
Remedy: Measure feedwater hardness and iron at the economiser inlet, recalculate demand, check softener regeneration and deaerator performance, confirm the injection point is downstream of the oxygen scavenger.

Symptom: Metal loss in the feedwater line near the injection point or in steam drum internals.
Likely cause: Chelant overfeed, slug feeding, or injection against the pipe wall.
Remedy: Fit a stainless steel quill to the pipe centreline, feed continuously in proportion to flow, bring the free residual down and consider a chelant/polymer blend run slightly below stoichiometric demand.

Symptom: Free chelant residual cannot be established no matter how much is fed.
Likely cause: Existing deposits are consuming chelant as they dissolve, or thermal decomposition at high pressure.
Remedy: Do not chase the residual with large doses; this is on-line cleaning and it can release deposits in pieces. Review whether an off-line clean is warranted and whether the unit's pressure is within the range suited to EDTA.

Symptom: Elevated copper in boiler water.
Likely cause: Chelant fed upstream of copper alloy feedwater heaters or pumps.
Remedy: Relocate the injection point downstream of copper-bearing equipment.

Symptom: RO normalised flow does not recover after an alkaline EDTA clean.
Likely cause: The foulant is not one EDTA removes (silica, barium sulfate, heavy iron), the solution was exhausted, or the soak was too short.
Remedy: Analyse the spent cleaning solution and, if possible, autopsy a tail element. Follow with an acid clean for carbonate and iron; repeat with fresh solution and a longer soak for sulfate scale.

Symptom: White crystals in a liquid EDTA storage tank in winter.
Likely cause: Crystallisation at low temperature.
Remedy: Warm and recirculate; the product redissolves without loss of quality. Insulate or trace-heat the tank and lines.

Symptom: Brown sludge forms in a caustic cleaning bath containing EDTA.
Likely cause: At pH above 12, iron leaves the EDTA complex and precipitates as hydroxide.
Remedy: Add sodium gluconate or supplement with a DTPA-type chelant for iron.

Symptom: Effluent fails copper or nickel limits after a chelant-based cleaner was introduced.
Likely cause: The metals are held in solution by EDTA through the hydroxide precipitation step.
Remedy: Segregate the stream and apply a decomplexation treatment such as displacement with ferric iron and lime, organosulfide precipitation or oxidation.

Symptom: Fading or indistinct endpoint in the hardness titration.
Likely cause: Interfering metals (copper, iron, manganese) or an aged indicator.
Remedy: Add the appropriate inhibitor, use fresh indicator, and titrate promptly after buffering.



EDTA VERSUS OTHER WATER TREATMENT CHEMISTRIES

EDTA is one tool among several. Placing it beside the alternatives makes the selection logic clear.

EDTA vs phosphonates (HEDP, ATMP, PBTC). Phosphonates are threshold inhibitors: a few mg/L delays scale formation from water carrying hundreds of mg/L of hardness. They tolerate chlorine reasonably well and are the backbone of cooling water treatment. They prevent scale but dissolve existing scale only slowly. EDTA prevents scale only up to its stoichiometric capacity but dissolves existing deposits effectively. Rule of thumb: phosphonate to keep a system clean, EDTA to get it clean.

EDTA vs polymers (polyacrylates, maleic and sulfonated copolymers). Polymers disperse particles and distort crystals; they do not chelate in any quantitative sense. In boilers they complement EDTA by carrying iron oxide. All-polymer programmes avoid the risk of chelant corrosion and are often chosen for that reason.

EDTA vs phosphate boiler programmes. Phosphate precipitates hardness as a manageable sludge and is tolerant of feedwater upsets. Chelant gives cleaner surfaces but demands better feedwater and closer control.

EDTA vs NTA. NTA is a smaller, weaker chelant with higher capacity per kilogram and better biodegradability. It was widely used in boiler treatment at lower pressures. Its classification in the European Union as a suspected carcinogen has reduced its use considerably.

EDTA vs DTPA. DTPA has eight binding sites, holds iron and manganese at higher pH and under oxidising conditions, and is the preferred chelant for barium sulfate dissolvers. It costs more per unit of chelating capacity.

EDTA vs citric acid. Citric acid is an effective, biodegradable cleaner for iron oxide and carbonate at acidic pH and is the standard low-pH membrane cleaner. Its complexes are much weaker than those of EDTA, and it does little for sulfate scale.

EDTA vs sodium gluconate. Gluconate is a weak sequestrant at neutral pH but an excellent one for iron and aluminium in strong caustic, exactly where EDTA falters. The two are natural partners in alkaline cleaners.

EDTA vs GLDA and MGDA. These readily biodegradable aminocarboxylates approach EDTA in calcium binding and are chosen where biodegradability is a formal requirement. They are generally more expensive and somewhat weaker on heavy metals.

EDTA vs mineral acids for descaling. Hydrochloric and sulfamic acids are quick and cheap on carbonate scale. EDTA is slower and costlier but handles sulfate scale, spares sensitive metallurgy, adds no chloride and evolves no gas.

Summed up: where a defined quantity of metal must be held or dissolved reliably across a broad pH range, EDTA remains the benchmark. Where the task is to restrain a large excess of hardness with a small dose, to operate in chlorinated water, or to meet a biodegradability requirement, another chemistry is the better fit. Many of the best programmes use two of these together.


SAFETY, HEALTH AND HANDLING

Is EDTA hazardous? The answer depends on the form and the route of exposure.

Classification (GHS/CLP)

EDTA acid: causes serious eye irritation (H319).
Tetrasodium EDTA: safety data sheets commonly carry harmful if swallowed (H302), causes serious eye damage (H318), harmful if inhaled (H332) and may cause damage to the respiratory tract through prolonged or repeated inhalation (H373). Signal word: Danger.
Disodium EDTA: harmful if inhaled (H332) and may cause damage to the respiratory tract through prolonged or repeated inhalation (H373).

Classifications are revised from time to time. The current safety data sheet (SDS) for the product actually delivered is the authoritative document.

The inhalation hazards relate to fine dust breathed over long periods; liquid products and enclosed handling largely remove that exposure. The eye hazard of tetrasodium EDTA stems from its strong alkalinity.

Personal protection. For powders: local exhaust ventilation, a particulate respirator (P2/N95 class or better) where dust is generated, tight-fitting goggles, chemical-resistant gloves and work clothing. For liquid tetrasodium EDTA: goggles or a face shield during transfer, gloves and an eyewash station within reach.

First aid.
Eyes: rinse immediately with plenty of water for at least 15 minutes, holding the eyelids apart; remove contact lenses; seek medical attention without delay.
Skin: remove contaminated clothing and wash with soap and water.
Inhalation: move to fresh air; seek medical advice if symptoms persist.
Ingestion: rinse the mouth, do not induce vomiting, obtain medical advice.

Longer-term health profile. EDTA and its salts are not classified as carcinogenic, mutagenic or toxic to reproduction. Absorption from the gut is low and what is absorbed is excreted unchanged by the kidneys. Effects seen at very high doses are linked to depletion of essential metals such as zinc. Skin absorption is negligible.

Fire and spills. EDTA is not flammable, although like any fine organic powder a dust cloud can ignite under the right conditions. Combustion can release nitrogen oxides and carbon oxides. Water spray, foam and dry chemical are suitable extinguishing media. Sweep up spilled powder without raising dust; absorb liquid spills with inert material. Floors wetted with tetrasodium EDTA solution are slippery.

Special caution for cleaning operations. Spent EDTA cleaning solutions carry the dissolved metals from the deposit, sometimes including copper, nickel or chromium, and may be hot and ammoniacal. Their handling and disposal fall under waste regulations and should be planned before the job begins.


ENVIRONMENTAL PROFILE AND DISCHARGE CONSIDERATIONS

The environmental discussion around EDTA is about persistence, not toxicity. Acute toxicity to aquatic organisms is low and the substance does not bioaccumulate. It is, however, not readily biodegradable in standard tests, passes largely unchanged through conventional activated sludge plants and is measurable in rivers downstream of populated and industrial areas.

Sunlight is the principal natural sink. The ferric-EDTA complex is highly photo-active and breaks down within minutes to hours in clear, sunlit water, far more slowly in deep or turbid water. Other metal complexes are more persistent. Biological degradation has been demonstrated in treatment plants operated under suitable conditions, notably alkaline pH and long sludge age, but cannot be assumed in an ordinary works.

A further concern is the potential of EDTA to keep heavy metals mobile or to remobilise them from sediments. At typical environmental concentrations the effect is considered limited, but it is a sound reason for large users to monitor what they discharge.

What this means in practice:

Check your discharge consent. Some permits and some regional regulations limit chelating agents or require them to be declared.
Check your customers' requirements. Certain eco-label schemes for detergents and cleaning products exclude EDTA; products aiming for those labels use GLDA, MGDA or citrate instead.
Dose to calculated demand, soften the make-up water first where feasible, and segregate chelant-rich waste streams. Each of these reduces both cost and environmental load.


STORAGE, PACKAGING, SHELF LIFE AND TRANSPORT

Storage of solids. Keep powders and granules dry, cool and in the original closed packaging, on pallets and away from walls. Tetrasodium EDTA is hygroscopic; reseal part-used bags. Caked product is not degraded chemically but is harder to dose.

Storage of liquids. Protect tetrasodium EDTA solution from freezing. Crystallisation may occur at low temperature and reverses on warming and mixing. Use tanks of stainless steel, polyethylene or glass-reinforced plastic with compatible pumps and seals; avoid aluminium, galvanised steel, copper alloys and unlined carbon steel. Vent the tank and provide secondary containment as for any alkaline liquid.

Keep apart from strong oxidisers (hypochlorite, chlorates, permanganates, concentrated peroxide), strong acids (which react exothermically with the tetrasodium salt and precipitate the acid form) and reactive metal powders.

Packaging. Solids are commonly supplied in 25 kg bags with a polyethylene liner and in big bags for bulk users. Liquids are supplied in drums, intermediate bulk containers of about 1,000 litres and road tankers.

Shelf life. EDTA and its salts are chemically stable. Stored correctly in unopened packaging, product keeps its specification for the period stated by the manufacturer, commonly two years or longer, and can usually be re-qualified by analysis thereafter.

Transport. EDTA acid, disodium EDTA and tetrasodium EDTA are generally not classified as dangerous goods for road (ADR), sea (IMDG) or air (IATA) transport; section 14 of the SDS confirms the status of the specific product. For customs purposes EDTA and its salts fall under heading 29.22 of the Harmonized System (oxygen-function amino compounds); the full tariff code should be confirmed with a customs broker.


SPECIFICATION PARAMETERS: READING A CERTIFICATE OF ANALYSIS

Assay (% active). Determines real chelating power. Check the basis: anhydrous salt, hydrate or acid equivalent.
Chelation value (mg CaCO3/g). The most direct basis for comparing products and offers.
pH (1% or 5% solution). Confirms the salt form: about 10.5-11.5 for tetrasodium EDTA, about 4-5 for disodium EDTA.
NTA content (%). Indicator of process and purification; relevant where NTA is restricted or must be declared.
Iron (mg/kg). The metal load the product itself brings; matters in colour-sensitive and high-purity applications.
Heavy metals (mg/kg). Required for food-plant, pharmaceutical-plant and potable-related uses.
Chloride and sulfate (%). Reflect the acidification and washing steps; chloride is watched for stainless steel systems and boiler cleaning.
Free alkalinity (liquid products). Affects formulation pH and compatibility.
Density and colour (liquid products). Quick identity and consistency checks at goods-in.
Water-insoluble matter and solution clarity. Predict haze in clear formulations and blockages in dosing equipment.
Bulk density and particle size (powders). Relevant to powder blends and dissolving behaviour.

Grades in brief. Technical or industrial grade covers boiler treatment, cleaning, textile, paper and general water treatment. Higher-purity grades with low NTA and low heavy metals are specified for cleaning in food, beverage and pharmaceutical plants. Analytical reagent grade is used for laboratory titrants. Ask for the current TDS and recent COAs at the quotation stage; typical values differ between producers.


BUYER'S CHECKLIST: WHAT TO SETTLE BEFORE REQUESTING A QUOTATION

EDTA price cannot be reduced to a single figure, because it depends on variables the buyer controls. Settling the points below produces comparable offers.

1) Which form? Acid, disodium, tetrasodium powder, tetrasodium liquid, or an ammonium salt solution. Quote the CAS number.
2) Solid or liquid? With liquid you pay freight on water but gain easy dosing and no dust. Powder generally wins over long distances and small volumes; liquid for nearby, continuous consumption.
3) Active content on which basis? Compare cost per kilogram of calcium carbonate chelated.
4) Which application and which purity? Boiler feed, membrane cleaning in a food plant and laboratory use have different requirements.
5) Limits on impurities? State any limits on NTA, iron, chloride or heavy metals at the outset.
6) Volume and delivery pattern? Annual demand, lot size, packaging and delivery terms all affect price and lead time.
7) Approval procedure? Plan for sample, laboratory approval and trial lot when qualifying a new source.

Price drivers include the cost of ethylenediamine, formaldehyde, cyanide and caustic soda, energy, exchange rates, freight, product form and purity, packaging and order size. A current price is therefore always quoted against a specific enquiry.

Documents you can request:

Technical data sheet (TDS) with specification ranges and typical properties.
Safety data sheet (SDS) in the required language and regulatory format.
Certificate of analysis (COA) for each lot shipped.
Origin, manufacturer and batch traceability information.
Statement of regulatory status under REACH and equivalent chemical registration schemes.
Application-specific declarations where applicable, for example suitability statements for use in food-plant cleaning products, or halal and kosher certification, evaluated on request according to product and grade.


SOURCING EDTA FROM ATAMAN KIMYA

Buying a chelating agent for water treatment is seldom a matter of picking one line from a catalogue. A service company may need tetrasodium EDTA liquid for boiler blends, powder for membrane cleaners and EDTA acid for a cleaning contract, each with its own specification, packaging and paperwork. Ataman Kimya supplies the forms of EDTA discussed on this page, together with the complementary chemistries mentioned in the comparison section, so that these needs can be handled through one supplier.

What technical buyers and formulators tell us they value:

Help choosing the right form. Send us your application, water analysis, operating pH and target metals, and we will work through with you which salt, grade and physical form fits. If EDTA is not the right answer and a phosphonate, gluconate, DTPA or polymer would serve better, we will say so.

Complete documentation. Each shipment is accompanied by a certificate of analysis for the lot. The technical data sheet and current safety data sheet are provided at the quotation stage, and additional declarations for audits and customer approvals are prepared on request.

Samples for evaluation. If you are developing a formulation or qualifying an alternative source, samples can be requested for laboratory work.

Packaging and logistics to suit consumption. Options from 25 kg bags to big bags, and from drums to IBCs and bulk, are considered according to how you use the product, for domestic and export delivery.

Continuity. For regular consumption, a supply schedule can be agreed in advance so that production is not interrupted by a raw material.

To speed up a response, include in your enquiry: the EDTA form required (and CAS number if known), the application, estimated monthly or annual quantity, preferred packaging, delivery location and any specification limits. The Ataman Kimya sales and technical team will reply with a product recommendation, the document set and a current offer.


FREQUENTLY ASKED QUESTIONS

What does EDTA stand for?
Ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid. It is also called edetic acid, and its salts are called edetates.

What is EDTA used for in water treatment?
To keep hardness soluble in boilers, to dissolve scale and iron oxide deposits from boilers, heat exchangers and membranes, to control trace metals in process water, and as the titrant for measuring water hardness.

Does EDTA soften water?
In the chemical sense, yes: it binds calcium and magnesium so that they no longer behave as hardness. It does not remove them from the water as an ion exchange softener does. Because it works mole for mole, it is practical for small amounts of residual hardness or for batch solutions, not for softening large flows of hard water.

How much EDTA is needed per ppm of hardness?
About 3.8 ppm of tetrasodium EDTA on a 100% basis, which is about 10 ppm of 38% liquid product, per ppm of hardness as CaCO3.

Does EDTA remove limescale?
Yes. It dissolves calcium carbonate by taking the calcium into solution as a soluble complex. It is slower than acid but gentler on metals and releases no gas.

Does EDTA dissolve calcium sulfate?
Yes, and this is one of its most valuable properties, because acids do not. Alkaline EDTA solutions are the standard treatment for gypsum scale on membranes and heat transfer surfaces.

Does EDTA dissolve rust and iron oxide?
Yes. Ammoniated EDTA at elevated temperature is a standard solvent for magnetite in boilers, and near-neutral EDTA solutions remove rust from closed circuits.

Does EDTA dissolve barium sulfate or silica?
Barium sulfate only poorly; DTPA-based dissolvers are used for that. Silica is not removed by EDTA at all.

Is EDTA corrosive to steel?
Uncomplexed EDTA attacks carbon steel and its protective oxide, particularly when hot and when overdosed. Correctly controlled, with the chelant largely tied up by hardness or inhibited during cleaning, corrosion is kept within acceptable limits.

Can EDTA be used in high-pressure boilers?
EDTA programmes are generally confined to low and medium pressure boilers, commonly quoted as up to about 1,000-1,200 psig. Above that range, thermal breakdown of the chelant makes other treatment philosophies more appropriate.

Why must EDTA be fed after the deaerator?
Because dissolved oxygen degrades EDTA at feedwater temperature and the mixture is corrosive to steel.

What is the difference between disodium EDTA and tetrasodium EDTA?
Both carry the same chelating anion. They differ in sodium content and therefore in pH and solubility. Disodium EDTA gives a solution of about pH 4-5 and dissolves to about 10%; tetrasodium EDTA gives about pH 11 and is far more soluble. Once the final pH of the system is the same, their chelating performance is equivalent.

Can disodium and tetrasodium EDTA be substituted for one another?
Yes, provided the dose is corrected on a molar basis and the pH readjusted. One kilogram of disodium EDTA dihydrate is equivalent in chelating power to about 1.02 kg of anhydrous tetrasodium EDTA.

At what pH does EDTA work best?
It depends on the metal. For calcium and magnesium, above pH 7 and ideally 9-12. For copper, zinc, nickel and lead, pH 3-12. For ferric iron, pH 1 to about 6.5.

Can EDTA be mixed with bleach or chlorine?
No. Hypochlorite and chlorine oxidise EDTA, destroying both.

Is EDTA safe in drinking water?
EDTA is not added to drinking water as a treatment chemical. Trace levels arising from environmental sources are covered by the WHO guideline value of 600 micrograms per litre, and levels found in practice are normally far lower.

Is EDTA biodegradable?
It is not readily biodegradable. Its main breakdown route in the environment is photolysis of the iron complex in sunlight.

How is EDTA removed from wastewater?
By advanced oxidation (ozone, Fenton, UV-peroxide), by biological treatment under specially adapted conditions, or, for concentrated solutions, by acidifying to crystallise and recover the EDTA acid. Complexed heavy metals are released by displacement, sulfide precipitation or oxidation of the chelant.

How do you test for EDTA residual in boiler water?
By titrating the sample with a standard calcium, magnesium or zinc solution to an indicator endpoint, which measures free chelant.

Liquid or powder EDTA: which should I buy?
Liquid for automatic dosing, dust-free handling and liquid blends; powder for long freight distances, limited storage and powder formulations.

What is the shelf life of EDTA?
Chemically it is very stable. Manufacturers typically state two years or more in unopened packaging stored dry, with re-testing possible afterwards.

Where can I buy EDTA for water treatment?
From industrial chemical suppliers. Ataman Kimya handles enquiries for EDTA acid, disodium EDTA and tetrasodium EDTA in powder and liquid form, with technical documents, samples and quotations on request.



GLOSSARY

Chelate: a complex in which a metal ion is held by two or more atoms of the same molecule, forming rings. From the Greek for a crab's claw.
Chelant, chelating agent: the substance that forms such a complex.
Sequestrant: a substance that keeps metal ions in solution and inactive; used interchangeably with chelant in water treatment.
Ligand: a molecule or ion that donates electron pairs to a metal.
Hexadentate: binding through six donor atoms.
Stability constant (log K): the equilibrium constant describing how firmly a metal-ligand complex holds together.
Conditional stability constant: the effective stability constant at a particular pH.
Chelation value: milligrams of calcium carbonate bound per gram of product.
Threshold effect: scale inhibition at doses far below stoichiometric, shown by phosphonates and polymers but not by EDTA.
Free chelant residual: uncomplexed chelant measured in boiler water or in a cleaning solution.
Chelant corrosion: metal loss caused by excess free chelant in a boiler.
Clean-in-place (CIP): cleaning of process equipment or membranes without dismantling.
Decomplexation: breaking a metal-chelant complex so that the metal can be removed from wastewater.
NTA: nitrilotriacetic acid, a by-product of EDTA manufacture and a chelant in its own right.



EDTA FOR WATER TREATMENT AT A GLANCE

Chemical name: Ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid
CAS No: 60-00-4
EC (EINECS) No: 200-449-4
Formula: C10H16N2O8
Molecular weight: 292.24 g/mol
Main water treatment form: Tetrasodium EDTA, CAS 64-02-8, EC 200-573-9, as powder or 38-40% liquid
Function: Chelating agent, sequestrant, scale dissolver
Binding ratio: 1 mole EDTA to 1 mole metal
Dose per ppm hardness (as CaCO3): 3.8 ppm Na4EDTA (100%), about 10 ppm of 38% liquid
Theoretical chelation value: acid 342, disodium dihydrate 269, anhydrous tetrasodium 263 mg CaCO3/g
Key applications: boiler chelant programmes, boiler and HRSG chemical cleaning, RO/NF membrane cleaning, exchanger and evaporator descaling, process water conditioning, hardness analysis
Not suited to: stoichiometric treatment of hard cooling tower make-up, chlorinated systems, barium sulfate or silica scale
Storage: dry and closed for solids; frost-protected stainless steel or plastic tanks for liquids
Documents: TDS, SDS and COA available from Ataman Kimya

EDTA has been solving water problems since it was first made for a dyehouse in the 1930s. Used in the right form, at the right pH and at a calculated dose, it remains the most predictable way to hold or dissolve a known quantity of metal in water. To identify the right EDTA grade for your system, obtain samples and technical documents, or request a current quotation, contact Ataman Kimya.




Ataman Chemicals © 2015 All Rights Reserved.